Our Research Methodology
How we collect, verify, and maintain source-traceable financial data without marketing bias or fabricated claims.
1. Source Hierarchy & Authority Rules
We classify all information into strict authority tiers. When two documents conflict, the higher authority source always overrides:
2. Handling Undisclosed Data
Many issuers do not publicly disclose fixed CIBIL score cutoffs or exact income criteria. We strictly distinguish between:
- KNOWN: The bank has published an exact figure in their schedule.
- NOT_DISCLOSED: The bank assesses applicants on holistic internal criteria without a public threshold. We never fabricate a fake minimum score.
- CONDITIONAL: Criteria depends on existing relationship, salary account, or fixed deposit.
3. Deterministic Arithmetic & Canonical Coverage
Audited: September 2026All GST calculations (18%), reward point conversions, fee waiver thresholds, and net yields are performed by deterministic application code using currency-safe Decimal arithmetic, never by speculative generative models.
4. CardIntel Score v1.1 — 100-Point Deterministic Scoring Engine
CardIntel strictly decouples objective product architecture from personal consumer spending. Every point is calculated from a published bank rule, raw verified data, or formula. Affiliate commissions and bank referral payouts have zero mathematical connection to card scoring or ranking.
- Dynamic Lounge Gate Modeling: Milestone-gated access (e.g. HDFC Millennia ₹1L quarterly spend voucher) strictly decoupled from standalone complimentary visits (0/10 standalone utility).
- Normalized Unlimited Access Valuation: Sentinel visit values (999 visits) capped to realistic benchmark limits (12 domestic, 6 international), eliminating distorted linear valuation inflation.
- Strict Legal Issuer Isolation: Enforced Canonical Card Identity Rule across co-branded card families; legal issuer terms (MITC fees, 0% forex markup, reward rules) strictly authoritative per variant.
Objective, standardized structural rating evaluated against the fixed ₹6,00,000/yr consumer basket.
Deterministic net annual return factoring your individual spending distribution, spend-waiver attainability, and lounge valuations.
Tailored alignment for category discovery (/best/cashback, /best/travel, /best/lounge, /best/low-fee, /best/fuel, /best/upi).
Calculates Effective Reward Return Rate across benchmark basket. Evaluated using lowest unrestricted published point valuation. 5.0% return serves as the 30/30 ceiling: MIN(30, Return / 5% × 30).
Recurring annual fee table: Lifetime Free = 12/12, ₹1–₹249 = 11, ₹250–₹499 = 10, ₹500–₹749 = 9, ₹750–₹999 = 8, ₹1k–₹1.5k = 7, ₹1.5k–₹2k = 6, ₹2k–₹2.5k = 5, ₹2.5k–₹3k = 4, ₹3k–₹4k = 3, ₹4k–₹5k = 2, ₹5k+ = 0.
Cap Retention Ratio = Actual Rewards After Caps / Uncapped Rewards. Uncapped cards receive 12/12. Cap Score = Cap Retention Ratio × 12.
Direct statement credit = 10/10, Bank-value = 9, Fixed-value vouchers = 8, Rewards catalogue = 7, Travel portal = 6, Transfer partners (no cash) = 5, Limited catalogue = 4, Merchandise = 2, Unclear = 1, None = 0.
Domestic visits (Max 5: Unlimited/12+ = 5, 8-11 = 4, 4-7 = 3, 2-3 = 2, 1 = 1) + International visits (Max 3: Unlimited/8+ = 3, 4-7 = 2, 1-3 = 1) + Spend condition (Max 2: None/≤₹10k = 2, ≤₹25k = 1, >₹25k = 0).
Stated issuer markup (excl. GST): 0% = 8/8, >0–0.5% = 7, >0.5–1.0% = 6, >1.0–1.5% = 5, >1.5–2.0% = 4, >2.0–2.5% = 3, >2.5–3.0% = 2, >3.0–3.5% = 1, >3.5% = 0.
Open retail / no published income = 8/8, ≤₹3L = 7, ₹3–5L = 6, ₹5–8L = 5, ₹8–12L = 4, >₹12L = 3, Relationship required = 2, Invite-only / private = 1, Discontinued = 0. Precedence rule: most restrictive applies.
5 fixed discrete pillars, exactly 1 point each: Travel (+1), Lifestyle (+1), Protection (+1), Fuel / Utility (+1), Digital / UPI / Payment (+1).
Base 5 points minus 1 point for each material friction: spend unlock hurdles, min transaction thresholds, manual opt-in/activation, redemption fees, or short expiry. (Caps are not double-counted).
5. Audit Case Study: SBI Cashback 1 April 2026 Revision
How CardIntel protects consumers from stale financial advice when terms change:
"Earn ₹5,000 monthly cashback purely on online shopping, making it a ₹1 Lakh/month card."
Monthly cashback is split into ₹2,000 max online (5%) + ₹2,000 max offline (1%), totaling a ₹4,000 aggregate cap. Digital gaming, tolls, and government payments are strictly excluded.
Provenance: Verified against SBI Cards & Payment Services circular ref SBIC/REV/2026/04.
